Advertising is the most ubiquitous rhetorical form in modern life; and one of the least consciously analyzed. Most advertising works precisely by not being experienced as argument: it presents itself as entertainment, aspiration, information, or emotional experience while quietly installing preferences, associations, and desires that its audience did not consciously choose. Learning to analyze advertisements is learning to see these invisible arguments; a form of literacy that is both intellectually valuable and personally empowering.
The systematic examination of an advertisement's visual and verbal elements, its appeals to credibility, emotion, and reason, its ideological assumptions, and its techniques for creating desire and motivating action; with the goal of understanding how it works and what it is doing to its audience.
Step One: Establish Context
Before analyzing an advertisement's content, establish the context that shaped its construction:
- The product or service: What is being sold, and what are its actual functional attributes?
- The brand: What is the brand's established identity, and how does this advertisement reinforce, extend, or depart from it?
- The target audience: Who is this advertisement designed to reach? What do we know about their demographics, psychographics, and the media context in which this ad appears?
- The medium: Is this a television commercial, print ad, digital banner, social media post, billboard? The medium shapes every element of the message.
- The historical moment: What cultural conversations, anxieties, or aspirations is this advertisement participating in?
Step Two: Identify the Rhetorical Situation
Every advertisement responds to an exigence; a problem the advertiser perceives in the market. The exigence might be: low brand awareness, a competitor's recent campaign, declining market share, a new product requiring introduction, or a reputational problem requiring management. Identifying the exigence tells you what work the advertisement is trying to do and gives you a standard for evaluating whether it succeeds.
Step Three: Analyze the Three Appeals
Ethos: How the Advertisement Builds Brand Credibility
Ask how the advertisement constructs authority and trust:
- Does it use expert testimonials, clinical evidence, or professional endorsements? What kind of authority do these invoke?
- Does it use celebrity endorsements? What ethos is being transferred from the celebrity to the brand, and how good is the fit?
- What does the visual style communicate about the brand's character? Minimalist design signals a different ethos than maximalist; high production values signal a different ethos than deliberate roughness.
- Does the advertisement establish trust through transparency (showing how the product is made) or through aspiration (associating the product with admired figures and lifestyles)?
Pathos: The Emotional Architecture
This is where most advertising analysis should spend the most time, because pathos is the primary mode of most advertising persuasion:
- What emotion is the advertisement primarily trying to create? Joy? Aspiration? Fear? Belonging? Status? Nostalgia? Security?
- How is that emotion created; through narrative (a short story with characters and arc), through music, through visual composition, through the people depicted, through the product's setting?
- Is the emotion being created by the advertisement or activated; drawing on prior associations the audience already has?
- How honest is the emotional appeal? Does the product actually deliver the emotional state the advertisement promises?
A life insurance advertisement might open with images of a happy family, then introduce a brief moment of vulnerability (a child asking "will you always be here?"), then resolve with a warm scene of security; all without stating an explicit argument. The emotional arc is the argument: love creates vulnerability; vulnerability creates need; the product addresses the need. Every image, every music cue, every edit serves this emotional syllogism.
Logos: The Explicit and Implicit Claims
Most advertising logos is implicit rather than explicit; the advertisement makes claims through juxtaposition and association rather than through stated propositions. Ask:
- What explicit verbal claims does the advertisement make? Are they specific and verifiable, or vague and legally safe ("helps support," "may reduce," "up to")?
- What implicit visual claims does it make? (Product placed next to a beautiful, successful person implies: use this and you will be beautiful and successful.)
- What causal arguments does the advertisement suggest? Are these supported by evidence?
- What comparison claims are implied? ("Kills 99.9% of germs" implies it kills more than competitors without stating this.)
Step Four: Analyze Visual Elements
For any visual advertisement, analyze the following dimensions systematically:
Composition and Hierarchy
What is visually dominant; what draws the eye first? This is the advertisement's primary argument. What is secondary, tertiary? The visual hierarchy encodes the rhetorical hierarchy: the most important claim gets the most visual emphasis.
The Gaze
Who looks at whom in the advertisement? Direct eye contact with the viewer creates a relationship of address; the figure in the ad is speaking to you. An averted gaze positions the viewer as observer of a scene. The direction of a figure's gaze leads the viewer's eye and implies narrative continuation. These are rhetorical choices about the viewer's relationship to the image.
Color and Light
Color is emotional argument. Warm colors (red, orange, gold) create urgency, appetite, warmth, desire. Cool colors (blue, green, white) create calm, trust, cleanliness, reliability. The color palette of an advertisement is a deliberate emotional argument calibrated to the product's positioning.
Typography
Font choices are ethos choices. Serif fonts (Times, Garamond) signal tradition, authority, reliability. Sans-serif fonts (Helvetica, Futura) signal modernity, clarity, accessibility. Script fonts signal elegance, personalization, femininity. Every font choice makes an argument about the brand's character before a word is read.
Step Five: Identify the Identification Strategy
Burke's concept of identification is central to advertising analysis. Every advertisement invites the viewer to identify with someone; a person depicted, a lifestyle implied, a community implied. Ask:
- Who is depicted in this advertisement, and what identity does that person represent?
- What identity is the viewer invited to claim through association with the product?
- What community does purchasing or using this product imply membership in?
- Who is excluded from this identity; who is the implicit "not us" against which the advertisement's aspirational "us" is defined?
Step Six: Excavate Ideological Assumptions
Advertisements do not merely sell products; they reproduce and reinforce ideological assumptions about gender, race, class, beauty, success, and the proper relationship between consumption and identity. A complete analysis asks:
- What assumptions about gender roles does this advertisement normalize?
- Who is represented, and who is absent? What does the racial, age, and body-type composition of the advertisement imply?
- What does the advertisement assume about what constitutes success, beauty, or the good life?
- What relationship between consumption and identity does it presuppose; is buying this product a form of self-expression, self-improvement, or social belonging?
For any advertisement: (1) What emotion is this trying to make me feel? (2) What identity is it inviting me to claim? (3) What claim is it making, explicitly or implicitly? (4) What ideological assumptions does it normalize? These four questions, applied systematically, expose the full rhetorical and ideological structure of virtually any advertising message.
Step Seven: Evaluate Effectiveness and Ethics
Finally, assess how effectively the advertisement achieves its purposes and whether its methods raise ethical concerns. Effectiveness is measured against the advertisement's own goals: a luxury brand advertisement that successfully communicates exclusivity to its target audience may be effective even if it alienates a broader general audience. Ethical analysis asks whether the advertisement's methods are honest; whether it makes claims it cannot support, exploits psychological vulnerabilities, or normalizes harmful ideological assumptions.
Take our free one-hour interactive course covering the complete foundations of rhetoric.
Start the Free Course →